Sunday, July 14, 2013

The Ire of Duterte Loyalists

A friend of mine, a well-educated woman, wrote her mind out in her blog about the recent tragic incident in the city. 

The way she presented her ideas on democracy, democratic governance and society, and human rights were done in a simple, sensible and civil manner hoping maybe she could shed light and present the other (mostly overlooked) side of the coin and provoke a productive reaction. 

Claiming it as her personal view, the article also had a tone challenging the manner how the local authorities handled the situation. No local media here, in my personal opinion, has ever written such a poignant article that "touched raw nerves." 

Despite the seemingly enlightened discourse of her blog entry, it was totally antithetical to the opinion of the majority of the netizens especially those living in Davao city and who are 'ardent supporters and trancedly loyal' to the current mayor and those who idolize Duterte even if they live from afar. 

When she gave permission for her blog entry to be uploaded on a Davao-based news website which has about 8,000 Facebook followers, the chaos began. 

The netizens' reactions were anticipated. But it was not the scholarly, productive discussion thing that took place. What came in were the rave of maniacal, rabid and blood-thirsty tongue-lashing netizens ready to tear her to pieces. 

Only a handful appreciated what she was talking about and commended how she bravely pointed to us the "more lawful" direction; and for showing that not all has yielded to that rising Culture of Impunity. 

There was name calling: idiot, ignorant, non-sense, they even called her a whore.

Did she deserve all of that? Hell, no! 

No one deserves to be chastised for speaking his or her mind out. She was talking of the commonly recognized but never understood, much more, practiced (esp. Davao city) concept of 'due process' which many of us might not fully comprehend due to our limited exposure and education. The concept of democracy and due process ,after all, cannot be appreciated in the streets.  So ironic, I guess, since we won our democracy on the streets.

Her distaste for the people's rejoicing over the public execution of the "criminals" was perceived as support to criminals and their act. With it, they wished her ill.

She wrote, she bled.  

But she deserved nothing of all that negative vibes and stress. 

I believe she got better education than most of those who lambasted her. She was way above their league, so to speak.  She is in the position to write what she wrote.

Given it was on the public domain like internet, and feedback is a component  of democratic dynamism, she took the reactions with a grain of salt. (If it were me, I could have treated it with a load of sh*t.)

The article (a blog entry, not a news story just to be clear) was not at all offensive. It talked about the rule of law, of the justice system however frustrating the process maybe, of human rights, of being civil and being human. If only our minds are open and our eyes are not blinded by hypnotic following of whoever has influence on us. 

Personally, I think the reactions were bordering somewhere between insane, comic and hopelessness. Some of them, only confirmed what she wrote, about how the scary culture of impunity has slowly crept in the consciousness of people. To give you an example, here's one:
".... Davaonos are different and our mentality of justice is different for a reason. We don't waste time in killing, yes KILLING criminals because the rest of the country is ineffective and completely incompetent in dealing with such matters...." - from K****** Marfori.
 Scary. Just Scary. 

Now, a lesson or two can be learned from my friend's experience. But, I appreciate how calmly, civilly, bravely and intelligently she handled the situation she was in.

At the end of the day, what is important is we stood by the principles we believed in. We have chosen which side we favored, for not choosing between the "white or the black" is tantamount to being dead.

Well, life continues. A beautiful one is ahead of us.

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Consenting to the Culture of Impunity

(I have forgotten about this blog. The blog which I intended to write feel-good stuff about Davao City and maybe about Mindanao. But now I might shift to writing more than just the feel-good things.)


It was the recent "shootout" incident in Davao City that prodded me to find a venue where I could vent out my thoughts on the issue. 

That fateful Thursday afternoon, I got my hands busy juggling with things both at work and personal matters. I had no idea what was happening in downtown Davao. When I logged in on my FB account, a seaman friend of mine, as of this posting was in Russia, sent me a PM asking on news about the shooting incident near Allied Bank in Claveria Street. (That seaman worked in Allied Bank before).

As I had nothing to share with him, I "Googled" it and searched possible FB accounts which might have info on the matter. My little research revealed me this info: 
Three suspected members of a kidnap-for-ransom group were killed in a shootout with police authorities in Davao City. Two died on the spot while the other died at the hospital. The shootout occurred at a bank in Claveria where the kidnap victim, who was accompanied by her abductors, was supposed to withdraw the P15 million ransom at around 12:30 p.m.
....Manhunt operations against the 10 other suspects who escaped on board two vehicles are still ongoing. Davao Mayor Rodrigo Duterte has issued a shoot-to-kill order against the suspects.  (News Excerpt)
And then, the flood of pictures and video, so gruesome I cannot believe people, most of them residents of Davao, were applauding them, sharing them on their FB timelines.  One newly elected politician posted the graphic video (shared more than 13K times the last time I checked) captioned with a harsh warning to criminals and would-be criminals messing in the city.

Either they felt victorious that bad elements were gunned down in their city where the Mayor pledged to keep them safe and secure by going after criminals and law offenders; or to show support for the local authorities, or for the sake of joining the bandwagon at that moment (another fleeting internet phenom.) Whatever reasons they have, I think it was so twisted to hit me to the core and led me to ask myself, "What has become to the people of Davao?"

I felt aghast at how they accorded praises to whoever they thought it was due, how condemning they were, and how "proud" they were of the bloodbath.  

(I opt not to post screen captures of FB postings as examples, since they are my friends and even relatives. We have dissenting opinions to the issue.) 

I am with you guys; yes, they are criminals, like those kidnappers, are menace to the society. But we are a community of human beings. We have laws. And criminals they maybe, they have rights granted to them by the democracy we all enjoy. 

So, where is the due process?  Whatever happened to it? We just couldn't kill anyone summarily. We cannot allow ourselves to become ruthless animals. 

I am pretty sure you will point out the "rules of engagement." They-shoot-first, police-fires-back. I've thought of it too. But hey, are we that intolerant to yield to the easy-way of getting things done. Remember they got the others inside the bank, right. 

I live in Davao City for half of my life, I have benefited from the strong hand of the local government against criminals. It made me feel at peace and secure. I am thankful. But it doesn't change my opinion on summary executions.


The incident was not a fictional entertainment. More that the actually shooting and killing, it involved realities of how we perceive democracy and the benefits it afforded us;  our reverence to human rights, or to basic grain of respect to human being. 

The local media was on their usual news stunt: straight, just-the-fact news of the incident. They were doing their job. I am not in the position to question them, but I was hoping for them, as the so-called fourth estate of the society, someone could have raised the question on the culture of impunity. And their stories to delve on the accountability of those in authority, just to provide the balance to the information being circulated among the masses; to help provide a clearer picture as to how people should critically create opinions. 

But none so far. This is a scary picture, that's all I can say.

Our actions and reactions, the causes we support, the ideals we fight for are a matter of personal values, morals, the kind of education we get, and the kind of society we want to live.

Should we condone the Culture of Impunity?



Let me hear your thoughts, too. Please leave a comment. Thanks.